If you encountered any problems with any spell, or have any other issues, please post here about it. You can leave a comment in the spell's notes to indicate it is under critique:
This spell is contested, see the [Spell Discussion] page.
Spell Discussions
Re: /Subtle Stench of the Deathly Draught/, shouldn't this be InAq 15? Where are the other 10 spell levels coming from?
(Yair added) You are quite right. I'll change the spell's level.
Spell List Discussions
Tyrrell's big list of level 3 spells
Level three is a spell level that any magus can cast. It is a level that is practical to get with non-fatiguing spontaneous spells. It is a level that characters can spont when they use no voice and subtle gestures, or when they are fast casting.
I chose to create spells that are directly derived from the published guidelines so the derived spells would not be controversial. I did not include wards because a level three rego (x) ward vs. creatures of (x) is somewhat useless and not particularly creative.
I have in some situations interpreted the guidelines broadly, perhaps more broadly than would be appropriate for a formulaic spell (see bits of beasts that betray for an example). But these are not going to be formulaic spells. It is a simple matter to limit a specific spontaneous casting to the situation at hand.
Meta/Site Discussions
How about adding pages for enchanted items?
Hi, this is a very useful wiki for ArM5 players. I thought it would be nicer if pages for enchanted items exist.
(Mark F added) I would gladly contribute to this added page for enchanted items :)
(Yair added) Feel free to either add invested powers rather than spells (I think we have a few), or create a new page for enchanted items and them there. Atlas' letters to us indicate they approve such (original) content. In fact, I've added one: see Enchantments.
How about writting the guidelines as found in the book? I like to cruise around and look at the spell on the wiki, but I dont always have my book with me, and it would be nice to look up the guidelines. (-Tarko)
(Yair added): This is NOT allowed. You may not post Atlas' text. You may post any guidelines you make up on your own (e.g. "I judge healing only the nails to be base level 4…").
